'Foreclosure mill' law firms smaller, less dominant after scandal

Video Courtesy of Channel 8 -- Rep. Shannon Behnken

Article Courtesy of The Tampa Tribune

By Michael Sasso

Published December 19, 2012

 Watch VIDEO


As foreclosures hit unheard-of levels in recent years, a handful of Florida law firms that operated as foreclosure factories reaped millions in fees.


One Tampa-based giant, Florida Default Law Group, had more than 1,000 lawyers, non-lawyer paralegals and support staff processing legal papers as cheaply and efficiently as possible.


However, some of those same law firms later were at the center of a national scandal in 2010 involving allegations of backdated and "robo-signed" documents and overall sloppy work. The Florida Attorney General investigated Florida Default Law Group, but dropped the case without finding fault.

Two years later, lawyers and judges say the worst abuses have stopped, and some of the mega-firms that dominated Florida foreclosure law have broken up or shrunk. In Tampa, Florida Default has changed its name to Ronald R. Wolfe and Associates, changed ownership and is now a smaller operation.

Lynn Tepper, a circuit judge in Pasco County, said the Tampa firm seems to want to leave the past behind.

"The attorneys seem to be doing a better job," Tepper said. "(The attorneys) actually seem to cringe when you mention Florida Default."

Well before the housing collapse, a handful of law firms in Florida cultivated relationships with the banks that service mortgages and with Fannie Mae and Freddie Mac, the government-sponsored entities that purchase millions of home loans.

By the late 2000s, those relationships paid off when masses of homeowners began defaulting on their homes. Some foreclosure firms began filing thousands of foreclosures per month around Florida, at negotiated rates of around $1,100 a pop.

The Tribune analyzed roughly 2,000 initial foreclosure filings in Hillsborough County in October 2009 to see who was filing the most lawsuits. The one-time king of foreclosures, Broward County-based Law Offices of David J. Stern, filed the most at 352 cases. Florida Default Law Group ranked second with 323 new foreclosures.

It's not clear how much money Florida Default Law Group's made during the foreclosure boom, because it was a privately held company.

However, the Stern firm spun off part of itself into a publicly-traded corporation, giving a glimpse into its finances. Regulatory filings show that Stern's revenues rose from $44 million in 2006 to $260 million by 2009.

Then, a massive scandal erupted around the country. In Florida, judges began targeting the Stern firm, in particular, and accused it of falsifying documents to speed up the foreclosure process. Major banks came under fire and stopped foreclosing on people until they could make sure the documents were authentic.

Finally, then-Florida Attorney General Bill McCollum launched an investigation into the practices of four large foreclosure firms: the Stern firm and Marshall C. Watson, both of Broward County; Shapiro and Fishman in Boca Raton; and Tampa's Florida Default Law Group.

That investigation eventually stalled when a state appellate court ruled that the Attorney General's Office lacked jurisdiction to investigate law firms' possible misconduct.

However, the scandal helped to change Florida's foreclosure law business nonetheless.

Law firms resembling foreclosure assembly lines still have a big share of the market, but judges and attorneys who defend homeowners say the foreclosure mills aren't as dominant as they were. New law firms have entered the picture and are helping to clean up things.

The Stern firm, by far the biggest foreclosure mill in Florida, collapsed when Fannie Mae and Freddie Mac told banks and mortgage service companies to stop hiring it in the wake of the scandal. Suddenly, the 70,000 foreclosures that David J. Stern processed per year were up for grabs. A second major Florida foreclosure mill, Ben Ezra & Katz, collapsed for the same reason.

In Tampa, Florida Default Law Group went through an ownership change that was a few years in the making.

Ron Wolfe, who had worked at the firm, purchased it in January from founder and majority owner Michael Echevarria and renamed it Ronald R. Wolfe and Associates. Today, he employs around half of the roughly 1,000 people the firm once employed during the peak of the foreclosure boom, Wolfe said by email.

Wolfe doesn't appear to have completely put the foreclosure scandal behind him. The Florida Bar still has an open probe into his firm for foreclosure misconduct, although a Bar spokeswoman wouldn't go into details. Wolfe said he expects the file to be closed without any finding.

A few judges around Florida, meantime, say they're not seeing the widespread abuse that led to the national scandal.

Lee Haworth, chief circuit judge in Sarasota County, said delinquent homeowners aren't challenging the authenticity of foreclosure mills' documents anymore, suggesting things have improved. However, the firms have done nothing to clear up a massive backlog of foreclosure cases, he said.

"They went from like a D-minus to a C-minus," he said.