State steps into Boca's Eden condo saga

Article Courtesy of The Palm Beach Post

By GRETEL SARMIENTO

Published March 24, 2008 

BOCA RATON — A state agency that oversees condominiums has alleged that Eden developer Boca East LLC has violated state law.

The investigation is the latest twist in the Eden condo-conversion project that promised four years ago to deliver "spacious outdoor terraces provide panoramic views of the area's breathtaking scenery." Living surrounded by piles of cement, dust and board-covered windows has been a four-year-long torture, Eden unit owners say. Until now their cry for help had been ignored.

The five-page letter, dated April 16, to the developer from the Florida Department of Business and Professional Regulation cites some of the violations residents have been complaining about for years:

  • Failure to schedule and hold an election to permit non-developer unit owners to elect at least one-third of the association's board. ZConducting a board meeting to adopt the budget without a quorum of the board members present .
  • Adopting a budget for 2007 without providing copies of the proposed budget to the unit owners 14 days in advance of the meeting at which the budget was considered.

Boca East has until April 30 to respond to the allegations. A call to a company representative for comment was not returned Thursday afternoon.

News of the state investigation offered little relief to Bernard Seid and his wife, Sheila, who say they feel like hostages.

"We've been trapped four years," Bernard Seid said.

The Seids have spent $50,000 in storage and rental for two winters. In 2004 they sold their Manhattan apartment and bought an Eden unit at 300 West Palmetto Park Road for $430,000.

"I'm 70 now. I was supposed to retire." Instead, he and his wife have been subject to "an emotional and physical nightmare," he said.

One of the outcomes of the state investigation could have Eden unit owners taking control of their condominium association, which currently is controlled by the developer. If the residents gain control it would be harder for Boca East to force them out - a move they anticipate if the city approves the developer's latest plans to convert the condos into an age-restricted rental facility.

Steven Platzek, an attorney representing some unit owners, fears if the city approves the plan, Boca East's next step will be to terminate the Eden association.

"It gets to be ugly and expensive and time consuming," Platzek said.

Eden residents have pleaded with city officials to help them deal with a developer they have described as "evil," "unfair" and "cold."

Yet city officials say residents' requests fall outside their role as a government body. Any contract issues should be worked out with the developer.

"That's a stupid excuse. The city is obligated to protect their people. Period," said Jan Bergemann, who runs the Cyber Citizens For Justice, a Florida non-profit group that has followed the Eden case for years. "The city allowed this to get this way. It gave new deadlines and more new deadlines."

Some owners have tried selling back their units to Boca East with no luck. The Seids also considered selling back but never heard from the developer. They are not surprised.

"Whatever he says to you after four years, you can't believe it," Seid said.


Altered Boca project irritates unit owners

CONDO ARTICLES HOME NEWS PAGE