For Florida contractors, a mechanic's
lien is one of the strongest tools for getting paid. Florida
lien law is also unforgiving, and it gets more complicated
when the work is performed on a condominium's common
elements. A recent Second District Court of Appeal decision,
Stein v. Reynolds Ventures, Inc., 51 Fla. L. Weekly D1627
(Fla. 2d DCA Aug. 7, 2026), shows how a contractor can lose
its lien after doing everything else right.
What Happened
Reynolds Ventures, Inc. contracted with the Privateer North
condominium association in Longboat Key and performed work
affecting all units in the community. When the dispute over
payment went unresolved, Reynolds recorded a mechanic's lien
that listed every unit owner, including Kenneth and Jill
Stein.
The Steins did not wait to be sued. They used section
713.21(4), Florida Statutes, and the clerk issued a Summons
and Notice to Show Cause. That summons required Reynolds,
within 20 days, to show cause why its lien should not be
enforced by action or vacated and cancelled of record.
Reynolds responded that it had not filed a foreclosure
action because it was still trying to work things out with
the association, and that filing suit would undermine those
efforts. As an alternative, it asked for fourteen more days
to file suit.
What the Court Decided
The Second DCA ordered the lien cancelled with respect to
the Stein’s property. Several points in the opinion matter
for contractors.
Individual unit owners can attack a common-element lien.
Under section 718.121(2), a contract with the association
serves as authorization to furnish the contracted for work
with the express consent of each unit owner. In other words,
each unit owner’s interest is subject to a lien for their
pro rata share of amounts owed to the contractor. Once a
contractor records a lien under section 718.121(3) against
the units, each named owner becomes an interested party who
can seek discharge of the lien on their own unit under
chapter 713. Contracting with the association does not limit
the contractor's exposure to the association alone.
This is not a derivative claim. The court rejected the
argument that the Steins were improperly asserting the
association's rights. They were exercising their own rights
as property owners. Expect challenges from individual
owners, not only from the board.
"Good cause" is very hard to show. The court said that,
absent informing the court that a lienor has already taken
steps to foreclose its lien, "rarely does a circumstance
rise to the level of 'good cause.'" Ongoing settlement talks
were not enough. The court also said Reynolds had conflated
two separate claims: its contract claim against the
association, and its lien foreclosure claim against the
individual unit owners. Trying to resolve the first does not
protect the second.
No extensions. Proceedings under section 713.21 are "special
statutory proceedings" that require strict compliance,
including strict observance of time limits. The trial court
has no discretion to deviate from those limits, and nothing
in the statute authorizes an extension. If the lienor
neither shows good cause nor commences an enforcement action
before the return date, the court shall cancel the lien.
Practical Takeaways for Contractors
-
Treat a Notice to Show Cause as an emergency. You have 20 days. Calendar the deadline right away and call counsel.
-
Be ready to file suit, even while negotiating. Filing a foreclosure action does not stop settlement talks.
-
Failing to file can end your lien.
-
Keep the contract claim and the lien claim separate. Your contract is with the association, but your lien runs against each unit. Plan a strategy for both.
Expect individual owners to act. Any unit owner named in a common-element lien can force your hand on their own unit.
Don't count on extra time. Courts cannot grant extensions
under section 713.21(4).
Bottom Line
Stein is a reminder that Florida lien rights depend on
strict compliance with the statute, and good-faith
negotiation does not extend the statutory deadline. If you
work on condominium common elements, plan your lien
enforcement strategy before you record. If a Notice to Show
Cause arrives, act quickly.